What to say to the staff, and what that first little pour is for.
Written by Missy WineSydney · 5 min read
That splash of wine they pour you first is only a check.
You’re making sure the wine isn’t faulty. Nobody expects you to say anything clever about it, and a nod is fine.
Here’s the rest, from choosing a glass or a bottle to bringing your own.
Ordering wine in five steps
Glass or bottle
Say your budget
Find the value
The first taste
BYO
One
Glass or bottle?
Depends on how many of you are drinking
A bottle holds about five glasses. If two of you want the same style and you’ll each have a couple, the bottle usually works out cheaper.
Everyone wants something different? Go by the glass. It’s also the easiest way to work out what you like, because you can try a few wines over one dinner.
Try thisAsk for a small taste before you commit to a glass. Lots of bars are happy to pour one.
Two
Tell them what you like, and your budget
A sentence or two is plenty
Staff can’t help much if they’re guessing. Name a wine you already enjoy and roughly what you want to spend. Something like “I usually like Pinot Noir. Something around $80?” If you’ve ordered your food, mention that too.
Don’t want to say a number out loud on a date? Point to a price on the list and say “something around here.” They’ll know what you mean.
Easy things to askWhat’s good by the glass tonight?Have you got something like a Pinot Noir, but a bit different?
Three
Where the value is on a wine list
Look past the cheapest bottle
Wine costs more at a restaurant than at a bottle shop. Often a lot more. The restaurant is paying for glassware and storage, plus staff and rent. When Decanter compared prices at top UK restaurants, most bottles cost three to four times the shop price.
The cheapest bottle on the list often has the biggest markup. Famous names cost extra too, because they sell easily. A grape or region you don’t know is often the better buy, since someone picked it for the taste and not the name.
Worth knowingSome restaurants add a set dollar amount to pricier bottles instead of multiplying the price. So spending a bit more can get you more wine for your money.
Four
What the first taste is for
Check the label, then smell it
They’ll show you the bottle first. Make sure it’s the one you ordered, and check the year. Then they pour a splash. Give it a swirl and a smell. Have a sip too if you like.
You’re checking for faults. The common one is cork taint, and people call a wine with it “corked.” It smells musty, a bit like wet cardboard or damp newspaper, and the fruit tastes flat. A wine with a screw cap can’t be corked.
Think something’s off? Just say “I think this might be corked. Could you check it?” A good restaurant will taste it and bring a new bottle if they agree.
If it’s fine, say thanks and they’ll pour. Not loving a wine isn’t the same as a fault. You can still tell them, especially if they picked it for you, but they don’t have to swap it.
Five
BYO and corkage
Sydney has plenty of BYO spots
Lots of Sydney restaurants let you bring your own wine. They charge corkage for opening and pouring it, either per bottle or per person. In Broadsheet’s guide to Sydney BYO restaurants, it goes from about $5 a person up to $35 a bottle, and a couple of places don’t charge at all.
Check the rules when you book. Some places only allow wine, and some only do BYO on certain nights.
Don’t bring a wine that’s already on their list. It comes across as a bit rude.
HandyBringing something special? Offer the staff a taste. It’s a nice thing to do.
Want somewhere to practise? Wine Bars & Eats lists places we’ve been to and what we ordered. And if you’ve done the wine personality quiz, your result comes with a line to say when you order.
Sources
Decanter, Chris Mercer, “How should I order wine at a restaurant?” (2022)
Decanter, James Aufenast, “Restaurant wine lists: get one for the price of four” (2020)
Decanter, Laura Seal, “In the restaurant: how to complain about your wine” (2021)
Wine Spectator, James Laube, “Wine flaws: cork taint and TCA” (2007)
Broadsheet, Broadsheet Editors, “Sydney’s best BYO restaurants” (2024)
Ask me a question
Got a wine question?
Ask me anything, from what to bring to a BYO dinner to what “dry” actually means. I’ll reply by email.